Antisemitism: We Must Not Be Silent
Where to begin? Kristallnacht – the Nights of Broken Glass,
November 9-12, 1938 as right-wing Nazis destroyed synagogues and Jewish
businesses, urged by Hitler and his officers, to stage it to appear as
“spontaneous demonstrations,” resulting in violence and death to Jews in cities
throughout Germany? The August 10-11, 2017 Unite the Right rally in
Charlottesville, VA, where young white men and women marched through the night
streets chanting Nazi slogans: “Blood and Soil,” and “Jews will not replace
us!” while carrying Nazi and Confederate flags? Or, last week, Kanye West
tweeting, “death con 3 on JEWISH PEOPLE…You guys have toyed with me and
tried to black ball anyone whoever opposes your agenda”? [i]
For centuries it has been like what the Hebrew prophet,
Habakkuk, 600 years before Christ, cried out to the Almighty: we see
destruction and violence, wrong-doing and trouble, strife! “So, the law becomes
slack, and justice never prevails.” Help us, Lord![ii]
The Lord God YHWH responds, “Write the vision; make it plain on tablets, so
that a runner may read it. For there is still a vision for the appointed time;
it speaks of the end, and does not lie. If it seems to tarry, wait for it; it
will surely come, it will not delay. Look at the proud! Their spirit is not
right in them, but the righteous live by their faith.” [iii]
The message from YHWH is plain to those of us who claim to
live by our faith: Erect a billboard, and write it plain and write it large so
that anyone driving or running by will be able to read it: Antisemitism is a
Problem for Us All !
There have been mixed corporate responses to West. The
sportswear company, Adidas, immediately cancelled West’s estimated $1.5 Billion
contract, and took all his licensed merchandise off the market. Twitter and
Instagram took down and blocked his accounts. Yet, Elon Musk, the new owner of
Twitter, posted, “Welcome back to Twitter, my friend.”[iv]
The facts. Since Charlottesville, attacks on synagogues and
Jewish citizens have been steadily increasing. Historically, antisemitism is
often accompanied by attacks on other minority groups. In the U.S, there have
been increased attacks on Muslims, the LGBTQ community, Asians, businesses in
majority black neighborhoods, and other minority groups and individuals,
according to the U.S. Justice Department’s and Anti-Defamation League’s
listings of Hate Crimes just for 2022. [v]
It is imperative for the Church to be involved, as some of
our New Testament texts, and preaching throughout the Church’s history by figures
like Tertullian, Origen, John Chrysostom, Jerome, Ambrose, Augustine, Martin
Luther on up to our day, has been used to justify antisemitism. Christians as
early as 1349 in Strasbourg, France, have led pogroms, organized
massacres, rounding up Jewish citizens, killing them and destroying their towns
and neighborhoods. I’ve known Jewish people in our time who were chased by
Chrisitan youth during Holy Week every year accused of being Christ killers. And
many Christians were complicit, or worse, silent, throughout the years of the
Nazi Final Solution: The Holocaust. [vi]
Fortunately, for Episcopalians, The Rev. Canon Leonard L.
Hamlin, Sr., Canon Missioner and Minister of Equity & Inclusion, Washington
National Cathedral, recently posted an essay, Sorry, Kanye West. You’re
wrong about ‘the Jews’. [vii]
He observes that often we tend to look past such incidents as simply
another celebrity or politician saying something outrageous. Yet, he points out
that: “Equally troubling, however, was the scene that played out on a Los
Angeles overpass where his supporters raised their arms in a Nazi salute and
unfurled banners that said “Kanye is right about the Jews. No. No. No.”, he
writes, “Kanye is wrong about “the Jews.” He goes on to remind us that such
figures of faith as Martin Luther King Jr, and Elie Wiesel warn that silence is
not taking a neutral stance. I’ve heard Elie Wiesel repeatedly say, “I swore
never to be silent whenever and wherever human beings endure suffering and
humiliation. We must take sides. Neutrality helps the oppressor, never the
victim. Silence encourages the tormentor, never the tormented.” People of faith
must speak out against hatred, division and strife.
I have spent much of my undergraduate years, seminary, and
life in parish ministry, attempting to erect that billboard to make it loud and
clear, “Antisemitism is a problem for us all!”
I have invited Holocaust survivors and their families to speak to congregations.
We have engaged in Jewish-Christian Dialogue in our communities. Yet, here we
are several generations later, and there are those who either think The
Holocaust is a hoax, or have simply never heard about it, let alone learn the
lessons we need to learn. Looking through years of my papers and sermons on the
subject, I ran across the story of a university teacher I had read about in
Harper’s Magazine, who, when teaching college freshmen about Nazi Germany was
met with students who could not understand what Hitler had done wrong. One of
her students described Hitler in a term paper as “a kid with a dream, who,
like a really big-time rock star, enjoyed a pretty good run at the top of the charts.”
This was in the mid-1980s!
The Good News is that when I posted Hamlin’s essay on
Facebook page, a former member of a parish I serve commented: “Yes, it is
VERY dangerous. My grandfather was German and he told me the early signs of the
rightism which surfaced there when the German people were starving and
vulnerable. This kind of propaganda finds victims at a nation’s most vulnerable
times, then the hate starts to spread like a cancer! We must ALL be aware!!
LOVE is the ONLY answer during these turbulent times. Love will cause helping,
understanding and sharing and ultimately win over evil and hatred. We need
AWARENESS.”
Habakkuk comes to such an Awareness. The prophet understands
that the Lord urges us to take sanctuary in the vision - If it seems to
tarry, wait for it; salvation will surely come… Look at the proud! Their spirit
is not right in them, but the righteous live by their faith.
A faith in which Love is at the center. As the priest Saint Maximillian Kolbe,
who gave his life in Auschwitz to save another man’s life, put it: Hatred
Destroys, Love Alone Creates. Like Kolbe, Habakkuk, and Jesus, we cannot
remain silent. This is our Faith – it is the Faith of Jesus the Jew. If
we make one choice today in the midst of ongoing hatred, division, and strife,
let it be Love. Amen.
[i]
Twitter, Instagram, Block Kanye West Over Antisemitic Posts, https://apnews.com/article/twitter-inc-entertainment-music-ba5c710ec59d195fe4d83cb2c9343589
[ii]
Habakkuk 1:2-4 NRSV
[iii]
Ibid Habakkuk 2:1-4
[iv]
Ibid apnews.com
[v] https://www.adl.org/blog/six-facts-about-threats-to-the-jewish-community;
https://www.justice.gov/hatecrimes/news
[vi]
McClaren, Brian D., Do I Stay Christian (St Martin’s, NYC: 2022) pp. 13-20.
[vii] Hamlin,
Leonard L., October 26, 2022 https://cathedral.org/press-room/sorry-kanye-west-youre-wrong-about-the-jews/?fbclid=IwAR28PsThIepmyhCTVQHOKdTECROMrYdVdN8LqENyxXT7Dmh9vfJcrlVGwvs